Law assignments in the UK follow a distinct structure that trips up many students, especially those used to essay-based writing from other academic traditions. Problem questions, in particular, are assessed very differently from general essays. Here’s what UK law markers are actually looking for.
What law markers look for
Problem questions (the “apply the law to this scenario” style of assignment) are assessed on precise, systematic application of legal rules to the specific facts given — not a general discussion of the relevant law. Markers consistently note that students who write broadly about an area of law, without directly applying each element to the facts of the scenario, lose significant marks even when their legal knowledge is accurate. Essay-style law assignments, by contrast, are assessed on critical evaluation of the law itself — whether it’s fit for purpose, consistent, or in need of reform — not just description of what the law says.
Common areas law students ask for feedback on
- IRAC/ILAC structure for problem questions — Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion — making sure each element is clearly addressed for every distinct legal issue raised.
- OSCOLA referencing — the standard for UK law schools, with very specific formatting rules for cases, statutes, and academic sources that differ significantly from Harvard.
- Critical evaluation in essays — moving beyond describing the law to assessing its strengths, weaknesses, and areas for reform.
- Case law application — using case precedent to support specific points, not just listing relevant cases without connecting them to your argument.
What kind of support actually helps
For law students, feedback that checks whether every element of a legal test has actually been applied to the facts — not just mentioned — tends to catch the most common, costly gaps. OSCOLA formatting errors are also worth a dedicated check, since they’re entirely avoidable but still cost marks regularly.
Getting feedback before you submit
If you’re working on a law problem question, essay, or dissertation and want feedback on structure, application, or OSCOLA referencing before you submit, we work with law students across the UK. Message us on WhatsApp with your subject and deadline for a free, no-obligation quote.